The Smith Island Sweet Shoppe, LLC
Smith Island cake is our family heritage
410-968-2200
Smith Island Cakes See our cake list
picture of a smith island cake
6-inch cake, $25 9-inch cake, $41.99
Welcome to the Sweet Shoppe
Here in Crisfield, MD we bake Smith Island cakes using our family's Smith Island cake recipe. We are Cheryl and Gary Tull, and we were born and raised on Smith Island. I learned to bake the 10-layer chocolate cake from my grand cousin Frances Kitching. Our specialty is Maryland's state dessert, a moist homemade cake with 10 ultra-thin, individually baked layers carefully stacked and frosted. Most every Friday night both my mother and my grandmother would make a famous Smith Island layer cake. Now I'm baking them for you!
How To Order
The hard part is deciding what to buy! Give us a call. We'll describe our cakes and help you select the ones that are right for your occasion.
Monday-Friday 9AM until 5PM
Saturday 9AM until 1PM
We take orders by phone and email, and we ship by USPS. Thank you for shopping at the Sweet Shoppe!
We accept Visa and MasterCard by phone
Gift Certificates Available
Smith Island Devils Food cake
Visit our friends in Chincoteague
Our friends at the Sea Shell Café in Chincoteague believe that by combining the finest available natural and organic ingredients with classic culinary techniques, you will enjoy a healthy and memorable dining experience. They serve Smith Island Sweet Shoppe Smith Island cakes!
A slice of school rivalry
The U.S. Naval Academy has ordered 4,660 miniature cakes to be served to midshipmen during Army-Navy Spirit Week. The cakes ordered by the Naval Academy are tiny versions of the traditional 10-layer confections that became Maryland's official state dessert in 2008.
Bookmark and Share